When I was in first grade, I had an art teacher who shamed me into crying in front of the entire classroom.
She had given us an easy assignment. Handing out blocks of wood, she asked us to draw faces on them. I loved art, and happily got to work drawing a man’s face. When I’d finished with his features, he looked more like an alien than a man, so I painted his face bright blue. (I blame my mother: she always read to me from her science fiction novels rather than from any of those boring children’s books.)
The art teacher went down the row of student desks, nodding and smiling as the children held up their wooden faces for praise. And then she got to me, and nearly went into one of those whirling fits of rage I now associate with Roald Dahl characters.
“You painted your face blue?” she shrieked. “You can’t paint a face blue! What kind of face is that?”
“It’s an alien’s face,” I said, tearing up.
I might as well have said “Satan.” The art teacher hauled me over to sit in the corner and made me paint another face while the rest of the kids tittered.
Now, this story happens to be true, but if I were writing fiction, I could have chosen to relay it from a different perspective. For example, I might have written it in limited third person from the teacher’s point of view, or from the point of view of the town sheriff, who is called into school after the art teacher is found dead. Or I might have chosen to begin the narrative after an alien invasion, during which the art teacher and several other people in town are abducted! Then I probably would have used multiple points of view.
Wrestling with point of view is something that writers do every day in fiction, and it’s one of the most frustrating—and fun—aspects of writing. Sometimes it takes several drafts before you get the point of view that works for a particular story. For instance, if you’re writing about an alien invasion, you might want what’s called an “author omniscient” point of view, which basically means that you’re relaying the story from on high, from multiple points of view or even in multiple time frames.
In Sleeping Tigers, my first novel, I chose what’s called a “limited third person” point of view—this means that I can only be inside the main character’s head, and nobody else’s. I did this because I wanted to create a tight emotional connection between my protagonist, a young woman named Jordan, and my readers, while still having the literary freedom to write lush descriptive passages of other characters and the setting (San Francisco and Nepal, in this case).
For my next novel, The Wishing Hill, to be published in spring 2013 by Penguin, I created the story of two women who are bound in ways they don’t suspect, so I decided to alternate points of view between them. That lets the reader discover their complex interconnectedness even before the characters themselves know what’s going on. I had to be careful to differentiate the voices. One speaks in longer sentences while the other has more hyphenated, staccato thoughts.
Now I’m writing a paranormal mystery. For this one, I initially tried a third person point of view for the first two drafts. I’m contemplating a first person point of view for the next draft to see if that will help ramp up the scare factor. Maybe the reader will be more likely to feel something cold and damp behind her in the hallway if she is the “I.” Using first person is an avenue for getting even deeper into the protagonist’s psyche; at the very least, if I try it, I can always go back to the third person point of view, having learned new things about the character, right?
Take a closer look at the book you’re reading or writing. What would have happened with another point of view? Try it—you might be surprised.
Toby Neal says
Ah, such a thoughtful analysis and now I look forward to reading the Wishing Hill even more!
It all came through Triberr great… I popped in from there to visit your comments!And as to your question- all the Lei books are limited third person, until the third one, Black Jasmine. Then, I have first person from the villain, and limited third from Lei. It felt like a big step into strange territory but it was called for.
Holly Robinson says
I love the first person villain in Lei–that was a very daring move, but I think it works well. It makes the villain feel like more of a threat when you hear her voice in that breathing-on-the-neck way!